Stopping rapist fathers having contact with children

Unpublished letter to the press by Lisa Longstaff, Women Against Rape

The campaign of Rotherham survivor Sammy Woodhouse to exclude her convicted rapist from contact with her son has opened ‘child welfare’ to much needed scrutiny. MPs agree that rapists must have no legal right to children born of rape (MPs call on change of law on rapist fathers after Rotherham case, 29 Nov. See below for details of new Early Day Motion in Parliament.)

But it’s not just the law that must change; the power of local authorities and family courts to socially engineer families must be curbed.

The law states that the welfare of the child is paramount, but in practice a (violent) father’s ‘right’ to contact often trumps the child’s right to safety. The mother’s safety is dismissed; worse, her warnings become evidence that she is ‘emotionally harming’ the children by ‘alienating’ them from the father.

As Ms Woodhouse pointed out, her experience is far from unique. The women we campaign with face similar injustices, whether their children were conceived by rape, or not:

  • An absent father convicted for domestic violence and drug dealing given residence of a child removed from a loving mother because she used drugs years earlier.
  • A convicted violent man the police consider a threat to life, invited by a family judge to claim his right to the children contravening an exclusion order.
  • A convicted rapist invited to apply for child residence after the woman he raped and her parents were dismissed as ‘unfit’ carers (she was mildly autistic, they ‘too old’).

These were not failures of law but of those who implement it. And of politicians who set the present direction by targeting single mother families for opprobrium and cuts. As the UN Rapporteur on Poverty said: ‘The state no longer has your back.’ It intervenes to police not to support.

Lisa Longstaff,

Women Against Rape / Support not Separation Coalition

25 Wolsey Mews, NW5 2DX

PARENTAL RIGHTS OF CONVICTED RAPISTS

EDM #1999

Tabled 23 Jan 2019

2017-19 session

That this House notes the case of Sammy Woodhouse, in which a man convicted of rape and serving a 35-year prison sentence was notified of family court proceedings for the child he fathered as a result of the rape; further notes that the man had no parental responsibilities for the child; regrets that Rotherham Council believes that it would not have secured an exemption to notify under the current criteria; further regrets that the presumption in the law is that a rapist is notified when decisions are made about a child fathered through rape; and calls on the Government to amend the Children’s Act 1989 to remove the parental rights of men who have fathered children through rape and to review the relevant Practice Directions to prevent rapist fathers from being notified of family court proceedings.

77 signatures at present

  1. Haigh, Louise

Labour

23 January 2019

  1. Barron, Sir Kevin

Labour

23 January 2019

3. Allen, Heidi

Conservative

23 January 2019

4. Black, Mhairi

Scottish National Party

23 January 2019

5. Moran, Layla

Liberal Democrat

23 January 2019

6. Harman, Ms Harriet

Labour

23 January 2019

In addition to the sponsors, the following Members have signed to support the motion.

Coyle, Neil

Labour

23 January 2019

Swayne, Sir Desmond

Conservative

23 January 2019

Davies, David T. C.

Conservative

23 January 2019

Duffield, Rosie

Labour

23 January 2019

Stringer, Graham

Labour

23 January 2019

Rimmer, Ms Marie

Labour

23 January 2019

Metcalfe, Stephen

Conservative

23 January 2019

Shannon, Jim

Democratic Unionist Party

23 January 2019

Sherriff, Paula

Labour

23 January 2019

Davey, Sir Edward

Liberal Democrat

23 January 2019

Antoniazzi, Tonia

Labour

23 January 2019

O’Mara, Jared

Independent

23 January 2019

Efford, Clive

Labour

23 January 2019

Hayes, Helen

Labour

23 January 2019

Ashworth, Jonathan

Labour

23 January 2019

Dodds, Nigel

Democratic Unionist Party

23 January 2019

Dromey, Jack

Labour

23 January 2019

Monaghan, Carol

Scottish National Party

23 January 2019

Kinnock, Stephen

Labour

23 January 2019

Reeves, Ellie

Labour

23 January 2019

Lucas, Caroline

Green Party

23 January 2019

Woodcock, John

Independent

23 January 2019

Creagh, Mary

Labour

23 January 2019

McGovern, Alison

Labour

23 January 2019

Walker, Thelma

Labour

23 January 2019

Esterson, Bill

Labour

23 January 2019

Williams, Dr Paul

Labour

23 January 2019

West, Catherine

Labour

23 January 2019

Sobel, Alex

Labour

23 January 2019

Betts, Mr Clive

Labour

23 January 2019

Gaffney, Hugh

Labour

23 January 2019

Brake, Tom

Liberal Democrat

23 January 2019

Moon, Mrs Madeleine

Labour

23 January 2019

Lucas, Ian C.

Labour

23 January 2019

Streeting, Wes

Labour

23 January 2019

Cooper, Rosie

Labour

23 January 2019

Vaz, Valerie

Labour

23 January 2019

Saville Roberts, Liz

Plaid Cymru

24 January 2019

Lake, Ben

Plaid Cymru

24 January 2019

Cunningham, Mr Jim

Labour

24 January 2019

Blackman, Bob

Conservative

24 January 2019

Bruce, Fiona

Conservative

24 January 2019

Skinner, Mr Dennis

Labour

24 January 2019

Onn, Melanie

Labour

24 January 2019

De Piero, Gloria

Labour

24 January 2019

Cryer, John

Labour

24 January 2019

Osamor, Kate

Labour

24 January 2019

Mann, John

Labour

24 January 2019

Shah, Naz

Labour

24 January 2019

McInnes, Liz

Labour

24 January 2019

Butler, Dawn

Labour

24 January 2019

Platt, Jo

Labour

24 January 2019

Reynolds, Emma

Labour

24 January 2019

Brabin, Tracy

Labour

24 January 2019

George, Ruth

Labour

24 January 2019

Perkins, Toby

Labour

24 January 2019

Lynch, Holly

Labour

24 January 2019

Onwurah, Chi

Labour

24 January 2019

Smeeth, Ruth

Labour

24 January 2019

Morris, Grahame

Labour

24 January 2019

Amess, Sir David

Conservative

24 January 2019

Buck, Ms Karen

Labour

24 January 2019

Brown, Lyn

Labour

24 January 2019

Vaz, Keith

Labour

25 January 2019

Snell, Gareth

Labour

26 January 2019

McDonagh, Siobhain

Labour

28 January 2019

Blomfield, Paul

Labour

28 January 2019

Pollard, Luke

Labour

28 January 2019

Ali, Rushanara

Labour

28 January 2019

Edwards, Jonathan

Plaid Cymru

28 January 2019

Davies, Philip

Conservative

28 January 2019