We are appalled that the Conservatives in the House of Lords are still challenging the repeal of ‘Presumption of Contact’ despite the years of evidence from campaigners about the danger it poses to children and their mothers. This has included campaigning by Claire Throssell whose two sons Jack and Paul were murdered by their father on his first unsupervised court ordered contact in 2014. No lessons have been learnt from this tragedy. As a recent case shows (see below) family court Judges are still ordering contact, even with dangerous child sexual predators!
The mother of a six-year-old child was forced to appeal a Child Arrangements Order by District Judge Beard which ordered her to make the child available for direct unsupervised contact with the father. The child has spent NO time with her father since she was a baby after he was arrested and subsequently jailed for serious sexual offences against children, crimes which took place over 10 years from 2010-2020. He is on the Violent Sex Offenders Register until 2032. The father had been in possession of 64,000 images and videos of sex involving children and the Judge noted that the father lacked any emotional appreciation for the victims, “a little area of nagging concern’ yet he deemed a six year old girl would be safe in his care!
As with most cases the mother was unable to secure legal aid but her counsel from the original case acted on her behalf pro bono. This shows how unfair legal aid is, resulting in many cases that should be appealed being unable to do so, putting mothers and their children in danger.
CAFCASS (Children and Family Court Advisory and Support Service) on behalf of the child called for NO direct contact given the father’s crimes as well as the effect this would have on the mother’s mental health but this was ignored. Judge Beard also ignored concerns by the probation service which assessed the father as posing a high risk of serious harm to children and women with offences occurring over a long period and it appeared that the father had no intention of stopping his offending behaviour!
Judge Beard ignored all professionals’ concerns about the father and instead blamed the mother, saying “I believe that the mother needs therapy and it should commence as soon as possible”. Did he really think that the mother having therapy would ensure the child was safe? This outrageous disregard for the safety of a young child and her mother shows yet again how the family court puts children in danger when ordering unsupervised contact with violent fathers.
The appeal succeeded and the case will now be reheard but it begs the question as to why this Judge is allowed to hear cases of such grave magnitude and ignore the real dangers to children! Judge Beard must be removed from all family court cases as a matter of urgency.
Read the judgement here: https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWFC/OJ/2026/337.html
Please see our evidence on Presumption of Contact; https://supportnotseparation.blog/2023/01/23/evidence-to-presumption-review-panel-about-the-presumption-of-contact/